Employee vs Independent Contractor | Barrett & Farahany

Helping employees find justice in eleven states with offices in Illinois, Georgia, and Alabama.

Employee vs. Independent Contractor: Legal Distinctions and Implications

Employee vs. Independent Contractor: Legal Distinctions and Implications

employee vs. independent contractor

The difference between an employee and an independent contractor is more than semantics; it carries significant legal implications, especially in the realm of employment law.

If you’re not sure as to what kind of rights you’re afforded as an independent contractor vs. a salaried/full-time employee, you need find out. It’s crucial to understand the differences between contractors and employees and the consequences of misclassifying them to protect yourself. The employment law attorneys at Barrett & Farahany can help.

Legal Distinctions Between Employees and Independent Contractors

An employee is someone who works for an employer under an agreed-upon contract of employment. In this arrangement, the employer typically has direct control over the work, including the tasks performed, work hours, and the overall work environment.

An independent contractor, on the other hand, is an individual or business entity that offers services to another under the terms of a contract or agreement. Unlike employees, independent contractors have more autonomy in how they complete their work. They may set their own schedules, use their own tools, and are generally responsible for their own expenses within the confines of their contract.

The Independence of Contractors

One of the primary factors distinguishing employees from independent contractors is the amount of control exercised over their work. While employees work under close supervision, contractors maintain a higher degree of independence.

The Finances of Contractors

There’s also a difference between the financial aspects of the working relationship. Employees receive a regular salary or hourly wage, often with taxes withheld by the employer. They may also receive additional benefits like health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.

In contrast, independent contractors negotiate their compensation based on the scope of the project. They are responsible for doing their own taxes and generally do not receive traditional employee benefits.

The Temporariness of Contractors

Finally, employees engage in long-term, ongoing relationships with their employers, expecting continuous work. Independent contractors, however, are typically engaged for specific projects for a specific amount of time. Once the project is completed, the contractual relationship may or may not be renewed, depending on the needs of the employer and the agreement.

Implications for Employers

For employers, the employee vs. independent contractor debate carries several legal implications. Employers are responsible for withholding income taxes, Social Security, and Medicare from their employees’ paychecks. Plus, they contribute to Social Security and Medicare on behalf of their employees.

The status of an employee comes with a range of benefits and legal protections, which employers are obligated to provide. Independent contractors do not receive these traditional benefits from the company they sign a contract with.

Employers also have a greater degree of control and responsibility over employees. This can translate to increased liability for them in the event of workplace accidents, injuries, or other legal issues.

Independent contractors, being more autonomous, often assume liability for the work they perform.

Implications for Workers

Workers, whether classified as employees or independent contractors, face distinct tax implications that directly impact their financial responsibilities. Employees have taxes withheld from their paychecks and may also benefit from employer-sponsored tax advantages.

Employees also enjoy a range of legal protections, including minimum wage laws, overtime pay, and eligibility for workers’ compensation in the case of job-related injuries. They may also be protected by anti-discrimination laws and have the right to join unions. However, independent contractors are self-employed and do not have these same legal protections.

Job stability is a critical concern for workers. Employees generally have more job stability, with the expectation of ongoing work and protection against arbitrary termination. Independent contractors operate on a project-by-project basis and are not part of the permanent staff.

Misclassification Risks and Consequences

Now that we have established the differences between employees and independent contractors, let’s talk about employee misclassification.

Employee misclassification occurs when a business classifies a worker as an independent contractor for tax and legal reasons, but they are, in fact, an employee. According to a recent study, up to 2.1 million construction workers in the U.S. are misclassified or paid off the books.

Employers who misclassify employees as independent contractors may face penalties, fines, and other legal consequences. Reports of misclassification can trigger audits by government agencies like the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and the Department of Labor (DOL). Such investigations can scrutinize the employer’s classification practices, payroll records, and adherence to labor laws.

If an employer is found to have misclassified workers, it can lead to:

  • Back Taxes: Employers may need to pay back national, state, and local taxes.
  • Back Benefits: Employers must pay for benefits owed to the employee, including workers’ compensation, insurance, vacation, and sick pay.
  • Legal Fines: Misclassification can lead to class-action lawsuits, and employers may incur costs from liquidated damages and attorney fees.
  • Reputational Damage: On top of this, employers can gain a bad rep amongst peers and prospective talent.

If you are an employee who has been the victim of misclassification, don’t hesitate to contact an attorney for help.

Discuss Your Case with an Employee Rights Attorney Today

Misclassifying workers is a serious legal offense with far-reaching consequences. To mitigate this risk, businesses need to carefully consider seeking legal advice on their employment contracts and how they pay independent contractors. Working with an employee rights attorney can help employers sidestep potential loopholes and stay on the right side of the law.

Do you believe you’re a victim of employee misclassification? The skilled attorneys at Barrett & Farahany are here to help protect your rights. Get in touch with our employee rights lawyers, and let’s talk about how we can seek justice on your behalf.


Talk To An
Attorney Today

By submitting this form, you are agreeing to receive emails as well as text messages from Barrett & Farahany.

Barrett & Farahany

Georgia Office

3344 Peachtree Road NE, Suite 800
Atlanta, GA 30326

Alabama Office

2 20th St N, Suite 900,
Birmingham, AL 35203

Illinois Office

77 W. Wacker Dr. Suite 4500
Chicago, IL 60601


Existing Clients: 866-989-0120

Chat with us!

Do you want to chat?